Writings in Connection with the Donatist Controversy by Saint Augustine of Hippo — cover

Writings in Connection with the Donatist Controversy

Writings in Connection with the Donatist Controversy is a collection of theological works written by Augustine of Hippo during the late fourth and early fifth centuries.

The writings address the Donatist schism, a conflict that divided Christianity in North Africa. Augustine argues that the Church should remain universal and united rather than separating itself into communities that claim exclusive spiritual purity.

A central issue is whether sacraments performed by sinful, heretical, or schismatic ministers can still be valid. Augustine maintains that the power of baptism comes from Christ, not from the personal virtue of the person administering it, and therefore baptism should not be repeated when someone returns to the Catholic Church.

Through scriptural interpretation, historical arguments, and responses to Donatist leaders, the collection explores the nature of the Church, the meaning of Christian unity, and the relationship between faith and authority. These writings became highly influential in the development of Christian teachings about baptism and the sacraments.

"In the treatise which we wrote against the published epistle of Parmenianus to Tichonius, we promised that at some future time we would treat the question of baptism more thoroughly; and indeed, even if we had not made this promise, we are not unmindful that this is a debt fairly due from us to the prayers of our brethren."

This edition of Writings in Connection with the Donatist Controversy was translated into English by John R. King (1835–1907).

Read more...

theological treatise patristic polemic ecclesiastical history church unity vs schism ecclesiology doctrine and heresy authority of bishops interpretation of scripture

Public domain (US)·No sign-up·DRM-free·Real text, not scans

Pages
568
Reading time
18 hours 22 minutes
Pace
intermediate
First published
420
Language
Latin

1606 years later, still timely

Why Read Writings in Connection with the Donatist Controversy in 2026?

When North African Christians split over purity — who may baptize, whose sacraments count — Augustine answered with arguments that proved deeply influential in how the Church understands itself. These treatises show a formidable mind fighting a schism in real time.

Today's connection

Any community that argues over who truly belongs — and whether institutions outrank individual virtue — is rehearsing this debate. Augustine's case for unity over purity still structures those fights.

Church and schism

Unity argued against purity.

Valid sacraments

Does the minister matter?

Living polemic

Refutation as an art.

Perfect for students of early Christianity theologians and church historians patristics scholars

Share this book

About the author

Portrait of Saint Augustine of Hippo

Saint Augustine of Hippo · 354–430

Confession and philosophy joined; memory, will, and grace in living prose.

3 books by Saint Augustine of Hippo in the library →

If this one stays with you…